April 25, 2026 ~1 minute minutes read Admin

We spend months detecting failure. What if we imagined it first? 🤔

A premortem isn't pessimism — it's preparation. Questioning a PI's idea feels like insubordination, so we design experiments to find failure.

We spend months designing experiments to detect failure. We spend almost no time imagining it in advance.

That's the premortem: gather the team, say "it's 18 months from now and this completely failed," then work backwards. Known in decision-making circles. Almost never used in research.

Why? Because in academia, questioning a PI's pet idea feels like insubordination. Because sunk costs start on day one. Because "what could go wrong?" sounds like pessimism — but it's not. A premortem is structured. Pessimism is just morale damage.

The output isn't a veto. It's a checklist: "If X happens, we already decided Y." You're not preventing failure. You're preparing for it.

A lightweight version takes 20 minutes. Before a grant submission or new collaboration, ask the room: "It's a year from now. This failed. Why?" Three rounds. That's it.

The molecule is optional. The failure mode is universal. The same premortem works for a PhD thesis chapter, a committee evaluating proposals, or an engineer scoping a feature.

When did you last imagine your project failing — on purpose?